Strategic logistics and supply chain optimization, including freight sourcing, route planning, and load consolidation, can help companies reduce transportation and freight costs. These practices provide greater visibility and control over spend, enabling more efficient procurement decisions1.
What is Freight Sourcing?
Freight sourcing, also known as transportation procurement, is the strategic process of identifying, evaluating, and securing transportation services to move goods cost-effectively across supply chain networks. Unlike transactional spot market purchasing, freight sourcing involves systematic carrier selection through competitive bidding processes, typically Request for Proposal (RFP), to establish long-term contractual relationships with qualified carriers.
Benefits of Strategic Freight Sourcing
- Cost Savings: Shippers can see savings of 10-15% when competitive bidding2
- Carrier Quality: Access to vetted, compliant carriers
- Risk Mitigation: Reduced Spot Market Exposure (10-25%)3
- Service Predictability: Established performance standards with Key Performance Indicators
- Scalability: Framework for growth without capacity constraints
Ready to start optimizing your freight sourcing? >
Freight Sourcing vs Spot Market Purchasing
Spot Market Purchasing and freight sourcing offer different strategies for managing transportation costs. Freight sourcing focuses on long-term carrier relationships, negotiated rates, and consistent service, helping shippers reduce spend and improve reliability. Spot market purchasing provides flexibility for on-demand or irregular shipments but often comes less predictability in rates and available capacity. By understanding the differences between freight sourcing and the spot market, businesses can optimize their supply chain, control costs, and ensure more reliable freight movement.
| Key Differences | Spot Market | Contract Freight |
|---|---|---|
| Cost Structure | Variable by Market/Lane | Fixed with Contract |
| Relationship Longevity | Transactional, Single Shipment | Long-Term |
| Service Level Agreements | Rate Confirmations | Contract |
| Best Use Cases | One-Off Lanes/Shipments | Consistent Lanes/Volumes |
Sourcing Process Guide
The freight sourcing process begins with collecting and organizing historical shipment data into a standardized format. This data is analyzed and submitted to LTL and truckload carriers as part of a structured request for pricing. The RFP outlines the shipper’s transportation requirements, including service levels, line haul rates, and other relevant parameters. Responses are then evaluated to compare rates, service, and total cost of ownership, helping shippers make informed decisions about carrier selection and lane allocation.
Planning Phase
Before launching an RFP, shippers collect and cleanse data, analyze their network, pre-qualify carriers, and benchmark rates to ensure informed decisions and a strong foundation for the sourcing process.
RFP Launch
During the RFP launch, clear documentation, a defined timeline, structured communication, and established evaluation criteria keep the process transparent, organized, and efficient.
Bid Analysis
Once bids are received, shippers compare rates, apply weighted scoring, run scenario planning, and calculate total cost of ownership to identify the most cost-effective and reliable carriers.
Go-Live
The implementation phase finalizes carrier selection, designates backups, allocates lanes strategically, and structures volume commitments to maximize performance, reduce risk, and secure optimal pricing.
LTL vs Truckload Freight Sourcing Differences
LTL Sourcing Characteristics
Pricing for LTL is generally based on freight class and density, making accurate dimensions essential for rate precision. A carrier’s terminal network coverage plays a critical role, and accessorial charges can significantly impact total cost. LTL sourcing typically involves a smaller pool of carriers, often 4 to 8 national or regional providers, and usually requires a longer implementation timeline of 4 to 6 weeks.
Truckload Sourcing Characteristics
Truckload pricing is usually calculated per mile or per load, with lane-specific carrier expertise and equipment specialization, such as dry van, flatbed, or reefer, influencing cost and service. Sourcing generally involves a larger carrier pool, often 15 to 50 or more providers, and can be implemented more quickly, typically within 2 to 4 weeks. Backhaul opportunities also play a role in optimizing pricing.
Key Components of a Successful Freight RFP
Depending on the transportation mode, different information is required to ensure a successful RFP. Below is a quick guide highlighting the key components you’ll need to include.
Detailed Freight Characterstics
- Origin-destination pairings with ZIP codes
- Freight volume by lane (monthly/weekly)
- Commodity descriptions and freight class
- Equipment requirements
- Accessorial service needs
- Seasonality and variability patterns
Service Level Requirements
- Shipping Hours
- Transit Time Expectations
- Delivery Windows
- Temperature Control Specifications
- Special Handling Requirements
Evaluation Criteria
- Price Weighting
- Service Quality Metrics
- Safety Ratings
- Capacity and Geographic Coverage
- Technology Capabilities
Contract Terms
- Contract Duration
- Volume Commitments
- Fuel Surcharge Methodology
- Payment Terms
- Performance Guarantees
Carrier Vetting and Due Diligence
When selecting carriers, it’s important to evaluate them across multiple dimensions to ensure safety, reliability, and operational effectiveness. This includes verifying compliance with federal regulations, assessing their capacity and capabilities, and reviewing their historical performance. Together, these factors provide a comprehensive view of a carrier’s ability to meet a shipper’s transportation needs.
Safety and Compliance Verification
Carrier safety and compliance are assessed through multiple checks. FMCSA safety ratings are verified via the SAFER system4, and carriers’ performance is reviewed across the seven SMS BASIC categories5. Operating authority is confirmed by validating MC and DOT numbers, while insurance coverage is checked to ensure minimum requirements are met, including $1 million in cargo and $750,000 to $5 million in auto liability.
Operational Capability Assessment
Evaluate carriers based on their operational capabilities, including available equipment, overall capacity, geographic coverage, and terminal locations. We also review their technology integration, such as EDI, API, and TMS connectivity, along with the strength of their customer service infrastructure and financial stability indicators to ensure reliable performance.
Performance History
Historical performance metrics provide insight into carrier reliability. This includes on-time delivery percentages, damage and claim rates, tender acceptance rates, responsiveness in communication, and a proven track record in resolving operational issues. Together, these metrics help ensure carriers meet both service and compliance expectations.
Ready to optimize your freight strategy?
Partner with Translogistics, Inc (TLI) to streamline your RFP process, source the right carriers, and secure cost-effective, reliable transportation solutions for your business. Contact us today to get started.
Frequently Asked Questions
Freight sourcing is the strategic process of identifying, evaluating, and securing transportation services through competitive bidding (RFP/RFQ) to establish contractual relationships with qualified carriers. Unlike spot market purchasing, freight sourcing involves systematic carrier selection focused on long-term partnerships, cost optimization, and service quality.
While actually savings varies by company, most find cost reductions through competitive freight sourcing and RFP processes. Additional savings of 2-3% are possible through optimized carrier selection2 and continuous network optimization.
A freight RFP (Request for Proposal) is a formal document shippers use to solicit competitive bids from carriers for transportation services. The RFP details freight characteristics, volume commitments, service requirements, and evaluation criteria. Carriers respond with proposals outlining their capabilities, rates, and service commitments.
A complete freight sourcing RFP typically spans 6-8 weeks from data collection through contract award. Implementation adds another 2-4 weeks for truckload or 4-6 weeks for LTL. However, modern RFP automation platforms can significantly compress timelines for experienced shippers.
Traditional approaches involve annual or biannual RFP cycles. However, modern best practices recommend supplementing annual RFPs with continuous optimization through mini-bids, market benchmarking, and quarterly performance reviews to maintain competitiveness throughout the contract period.
Verify FMCSA safety ratings through the SAFER system4, confirm operating authority (MC/DOT numbers), validate insurance coverage, check safety history through SMS BASIC percentiles5, and screen through industry databases.
No. While price is important, total cost includes service quality, damage rates, claims costs, and capacity reliability. Lowest-priced carriers may cut corners on service or lack sufficient capacity, resulting in higher long-term costs.
Footnotes:
- Dai,A. (2025). Approaches to Supply Chain Logistics Cost Optimization. Advances in Economics, Management and Political Sciences,164,177-183., https://direct.ewa.pub/proceedings/aemps/article/view/20830 ↩︎
- Translogistics, Inc. (2026). Why data‑driven transportation RFPs deliver 8–15% savings, https://shiptli.com/truckload/why-data-driven-transportation-rfps-deliver-8-15-savings/ ↩︎
- Project44. (2025). “The Future of Freight Procurement.” https://www.project44.com/blog/the-future-of-freight-procurement ↩︎
- Federal Motor Carrier Safety Administration. “Safety Ratings (49 CFR 385, Appendix B).” https://csa.fmcsa.dot.gov/safetyplanner/MyFiles/Sections.aspx? ↩︎
- FMCSA. “Compliance, Safety, Accountability (CSA) Program.” https://csa.fmcsa.dot.gov/Documents/Safety_Ratings_Factsheet_GRS_M.pdf ↩︎
